Donor Acquisition and Reactivation: Why Nonprofits Need Separate Strategies
- Shaff Fundraising Group
- May 8
- 4 min read
Introduction
In today’s complex fundraising environment, nonprofit leaders are under increasing pressure to grow their donor base while retaining existing support. However, donor acquisition and donor reactivation are often approached as one and the same—resulting in diluted strategies, inefficient campaigns, and missed opportunities.
These two efforts require distinct approaches. This article explores the strategic and operational differences between acquiring new donors and reactivating lapsed ones, and why separating these efforts leads to stronger engagement, improved ROI, and more sustainable fundraising pipelines.
Why a Unified Approach Fails
Treating acquisition and reactivation as interchangeable overlooks the fact that the two audiences are fundamentally different.
New donors are typically unfamiliar with your organization. Even for organizations with large inherited bases of potential supporters (i.e., higher education, independent schools, and patients), these prospective donors still require education, exposure, and the building of trust. Lapsed donors, on the other hand, already have a history with your mission. Their re-engagement relies on emotional re-connection, recognition of their past support, and relevance to what matters to them today.
A single strategy will either under-communicate to one group or miscommunicate to the other.
“Too often, organizations approach donor growth as a one-size-fits-all campaign. But the motivations and needs of a first-time donor are fundamentally different from those of a lapsed supporter. When we separate those strategies, we not only raise more—we build deeper, more sustainable relationships.”
— Brittany N. Shaff, CFRE, CEO, Shaff Fundraising Group
Acquisition Strategy: Visibility, Value, and Conversion
Acquiring new donors is about increasing visibility, demonstrating value, and removing friction from the giving process. This often requires:
Digital lead generation through search-optimized content, social advertising, or partnerships
Strategic storytelling that positions the nonprofit’s mission in a compelling, human-centered narrative
Optimized donation experiences, including intuitive landing pages and clearly defined impact statements
Email nurture sequences that guide the prospect from interest to action
Effective acquisition requires a long-view strategy that balances brand-building with tactical conversion.
"A successful acquisition strategy shows how impact happens—instantly and clearly. With focused narrative, we cut through the noise and invite people to join something larger than themselves. Paired with data-driven targeted outreach and seamless digital experiences, this approach turns interest into committed, values-aligned support."
— Jeff Neal - AVP, Digital Engagement, Annual Giving & Analytics at Loyola University Chicago
Additional resource: Unlocking the Power of Nonprofit Fundraising Analytics
Reactivation Strategy: Personalization, Relevance, and Trust
Reactivation should not be treated as a generic email blast. Donors who have given in the past should not be approached as cold prospects. Regardless of the last year they supported your organization, these supporters require a communication strategy that acknowledges their past support, addresses what has changed, and reinforces why their engagement and support still matter.
Effective reactivation can include:
Data segmentation by recency, giving level, and last engagement touchpoint
Personalized messaging that references specific campaigns, milestones, or impact previously supported
Multi-channel communication—including direct mail, phone, and digital outreach, inclusive of paid and organic social—delivered in a sequence
Low-barrier opportunities to re-engage, such as organizational updates or volunteer involvement. It is important to utilize engagement data that you do have access to personalize your reengagement content.
“It’s imperative that lapsed donors feel like your organization genuinely missed them and their contributions. Tell them what you were able to do in the past and what you hope to do in the future with their support. Personal recognition goes a long way in re-engaging a donor.”
- Melinda Phillips, CDO, Nashville Symphony
Additional resource: How to Win Back Lapsed Donors – Bloomerang
Key Differences in Execution
Factor | Donor Acquisition | Donor Reactivation |
Audience familiarity | Low | High |
Primary barrier | Lack of awareness or trust | Disconnection or fatigue |
Key motivator | Compelling mission story | Impact validation and appreciation |
Success metric | First-time donation | Renewed giving and long-term loyalty |
Typical tactics | Lead gen, digital ads, email acquisition | Personalized email, stewardship updates, phone calls |
Technology, Data, and Internal Alignment
Nonprofits should ensure their CRM systems are configured to support both acquisition and reactivation pipelines. This includes accurate tagging of donor segments, robust reporting by lifecycle stage, and integrated marketing automation tools.
Furthermore, teams responsible for annual giving, major gifts, and communications must be intentional and aligned on messaging, timelines, and audience targeting.
“When acquisition and reactivation strategies are intentionally designed, you unlock the full potential of your data. Too often, organizations lean on generic segmentation or outdated donor journeys that miss the mark—or worse, create a fragmented experience across teams. With the right infrastructure and reporting, teams can deliver coordinated, data-informed outreach that honors donor history, anticipates behavior, and inspires meaningful action.”
- Dr. Julie Knight, Head of Analytics and Reporting at Shaff Fundraising Group
For organizations without internal capacity to support differentiated campaigns, external partnerships or fractional strategy services can accelerate implementation without burdening internal staff.
Conclusion
Donor acquisition and reactivation serve different strategic purposes. When nonprofits invest in purpose-built playbooks for each, they not only improve immediate fundraising outcomes—they also lay the groundwork for stronger retention, higher lifetime value, and deeper donor relationships.
Shaff Fundraising Group helps nonprofits build and optimize these strategies with tailored solutions, analytics, and leadership support. To explore how your organization can benefit from a dual-funnel approach, contact our team for a free consultation.
Interested in participating in an upcoming SFG blog? Let us know!
Shaff Fundraising Group is a consulting firm specializing in fundraising, marketing, and analytics. We take pride in our independent approach, free from technology affiliations with SaaS and other companies. This allows us to provide objective, solutions-oriented support to our client partners and the broader fundraising and engagement community.
